The 2026 NFL offseason delivered blockbuster trades, headline-making free-agent signings, and franchise-altering decisions.
While every move looked promising in March, the start of training camp offers a better opportunity to evaluate which teams truly improved and which may have overpaid.
Here’s our updated report card on the biggest offseason moves heading into the 2026 NFL season.
Biggest NFL Trades That Already Look Like Home Runs
Los Angeles Rams acquire Trent McDuffie — Grade: A+
The Rams pushed their chips to the center of the table by acquiring elite cornerback Trent McDuffie. His coverage skills immediately upgrade one of the NFL’s most talented defenses, giving Los Angeles another star capable of shutting down top receivers.
The Rams strengthened an already talented defense by adding Trent McDuffie, who also ranks among the league’s elite defensive backs in our Top 10 NFL Cornerback Rankings 2026.
Why it works:
- Elite coverage ability
- Perfect fit in the Rams’ defensive scheme
- Instantly improves Super Bowl chances
Buffalo Bills trade for D.J. Moore — Grade: A
Buffalo finally found another dependable playmaker to complement its offense. Moore’s speed, route running, and ability after the catch should help stretch defenses and create more explosive plays.
Why it works
- Reliable WR1 production
- Creates more balance offensively
- Excellent value compared to market price
New York Jets acquire Geno Smith — Grade: A-
The Jets prioritized experience over uncertainty by bringing in Geno Smith. His veteran leadership and consistent decision-making make New York a legitimate playoff contender.
Strengths
- Veteran leadership
- Proven starter
- Affordable acquisition
Best Free-Agent Signings of the 2026 NFL Offseason
Pittsburgh Steelers retain Aaron Rodgers — Grade: B
Although Rodgers remains one of football’s smartest quarterbacks, durability and age remain concerns. The Steelers improve in the short term but still face long-term uncertainty at the position.
Pros
- Elite football IQ
- Veteran leadership
- Strong locker-room presence
Concerns
- Age
- Injury history
- Limited long-term value
Most Improved Team
New York Giants — Grade: A+
Few teams improved more than the Giants. Between smart free-agent additions, quality draft picks, and coaching improvements, New York appears ready to compete immediately.
Reasons for the high grade:
- Better offensive depth
- Improved defense
- Excellent draft value
- Balanced roster construction
Solid Underrated Move
Houston Texans acquire David Montgomery — Grade: B+
Montgomery adds toughness and reliability to Houston’s rushing attack. While running back trades rarely dominate headlines, this move could pay off throughout a long season.
Biggest Winners of the 2026 NFL Offseason
- Los Angeles Rams
- New York Giants
- Buffalo Bills
- New York Jets
Biggest Question Marks
- Pittsburgh Steelers
- Teams that traded multiple premium draft picks
- Clubs relying heavily on aging veterans
| Team | Move | Re-Grade |
|---|---|---|
| Los Angeles Rams | Trent McDuffie Trade | A+ |
| New York Giants | Overall Offseason | A+ |
| Buffalo Bills | D.J. Moore Trade | A |
| New York Jets | Geno Smith Trade | A− |
| Houston Texans | David Montgomery Trade | B+ |
| Pittsburgh Steelers | Aaron Rodgers Signing | B |
Final Thoughts
The 2026 NFL offseason reshaped the league’s competitive landscape. The Rams and Giants stand out as the biggest winners after making aggressive yet calculated improvements
while teams like the Steelers still face important questions despite adding proven veterans.
As training camps continue and preseason games begin, these grades could change, but several blockbuster moves already look like franchise-changing decisions.
FAQ
Which team had the best 2026 NFL offseason?
The Los Angeles Rams and New York Giants currently receive the highest grades thanks to impactful additions and balanced roster improvements.
Which trade was the biggest steal?
The Rams’ acquisition of Trent McDuffie appears to be the best value among the blockbuster trades.
Which signing carries the most risk?
Aaron Rodgers returning to the Steelers offers upside but also raises concerns because of age and durability.
